Geocaching is a treasure hunting game where you use a GPS to hide and seek containers with other participants in the activity. I don't actually expect them to make any of the changes suggested here; based on my experience thus far, mostly this is the /dev/null of suggestion boxes. The length of the hike is from the most logical parking area to the cache. Because the point of the difficulty/terrain ratings is not to preserve your precious D/T grid. However, when it comes to bugs their response is almost always admirably prompt and efficient. Data is cache-specific; lookup is log-specific. Add to Cart. The CO corrects the D/T ratings and indicates that they should replace the original values. Open your statistics page D/T grid. I fail to see how frinklab's suggestion would be any more conducive to this alleged "cheating" than the current system. Below is a post in the Changing a date on a historic cache (GC2DBE) thread. The difficulty rating covers time and effort in finding the cache (and possibly in signing the log) once at the coordinates. Imagine what would they would have to deal with if that vote for Scotland to split from the UK that was done a couple of years ago had passed. I'd considered that long ago as well, but ouch the amount of data to snapshot with each and every log would be unthinkable. $6.99. I do however agree that the ambiguities with St. Martin/Sint Maarten is worth fixing considering the number of geocaches that are actually impacted. Add to Cart. 1 Review. Fill this form with your Geocaching account information. Are you suggesting that the current implementation makes it harder to cheat at the incidental side games? That's about it the way I see it as a non-GS web app developer. The most recent post I could find was from more than four years ago, and isn't even really about the feature itself. If it changes afterword it's effect on grid completion, challenges, etc. If so, does that history include changes to the D/T? Quality 1. As a a dev in the health care industry, this is standard practice, and I'm a little surprised something like this doesn't already exist in some form. I wasn't thinking of the log poster making a determination which data to use, rather that the CO could choose not to save data that was erroneous, but keep the old data if something actually changed. Display as a link instead, × Thanks for reminding me. I mean, I think I get you're saying to store every cache edit in a snapshot form, and having each log use a back reference for which data to use, but that irks me as a database dev in this context for how to translate that to a simple user interface. popular-all-random-users | AskReddit-news-pics-funny-gaming-worldnews-todayilearned-aww-mildlyinteresting-tifu-videos-gifs-Jokes-movies-Showerthoughts-science Our Geocache Rating System can be used to help set the rating for your geocache. Garmin eTrex 30x 010-01508-10 Handheld Navigator Review. We're only talking about 35 caches or so. Project-GC is a site with the goal to provide statistics and tools for all the geocachers in the world. Rating: 100%. Add to Cart. Geocaching Gift Ideas; Gift Certificates; Clearance. Geocache ratings vary from one community to the next. The point of the difficulty/terrain ratings is to communicate the general nature of the geocaching experience to potential seekers, so they can better assess whether they should attempt to find the cache. All Rights Reserved. There are more than 3 million active geocaches worldwide.. Geocaches are hidden in 191 different countries on all seven continents (even Antarctica)!. Happy Holidays Collection; Wonders of the World; Celebrating 20 Years of Geocaching; Challenges and Milestones; Premium Member Collection; Novelty Items my subreddits. If someone wants to cheat by creatimg a dummy account, creating a cache, finding it, changing the D/T and finding again, who cares. Add to Cart. Project-GC is a site with the goal to provide statistics and tools for all the geocachers in the world. Featured. Rating: 100%. Geocaching by the numbers. Use case 1. In this instance, both D3 and T3 are respectively the 5th most commonly found. Because the point of the difficulty/terrain ratings is not to preserve your precious D/T grid. The Geocache Rating Calculator is designed to help cache hiders calculate the difficulty and terrain rating of a geocache. Then queries for a user's D/T statistics only need to take one extra hop to get data "as of" their find date. And processing would be a whole lot easier than with your proposed method, too. her having the initial cache info stored when I begin editing, or giving me the option to store the 'new' correct data would be nice and simple. Powered by Invision Community, at the end of the day this is a "bugs and features discussion" forum, Those that are implementing features at GS often don't participate in discussions, Of course the suggestion being this thread isn't perfect - no feature is. Therefore, a D1/T1 rating would be the easiest geocache to find, while a D5/T5 difficulty/terrain rating would be the most difficult. The relevant edit data is per cache, and if having a flag for a log for which data to use (by log date or current) then that would be per log. Items 61-120 of 217. Thats something I didn't think about. Of course the suggestion being this thread isn't perfect - no feature is - but it's not really that hard a module to develop, it's a transparent self-contained back-end add-on to the site under cache listing editing, and the hardest part would be integrating the new change log data with stats generation. The CO has also timed the publishing of new brass caps to coincide with many of the Mega Events in Alberta. Find-a-Cache. Determine what your 5th most commonly found Difficulty and Terrain ratings are (individually). I dunno. I still await a response to this, in the other thread: Here's a question for a forum-active reviewer: Can you see history of changes to a cache listing? I didn't realize this was where pro database designers criticized helpful suggestions (actually, I realize it wasn't even original; frinklabs asked essentially the same thing in June 2014). Fixing the St.Martin/Sint Maartan issue would be relatively easy. In any case, it's just an idea in line with this request. Please try to rate your cache accurately. Geocaching Gift Ideas; Gift Certificates; Clearance. At some point you have to stop trying to "improve" the feature with additional complications and start considering whether the feature is really that interesting now that we've started to understand how much effort it will take. Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. This way you can be sure, your D-T-grid does not change so easily. Looking at the threads about people who claim finds when they didn't actually find it, presumably enough people do cheat for it to be considered an issue. 3 Reviews. I didn't see anything unwelcoming in the responses you got to your suggestion. Items On sale; Last Chance Items; Account . A CO creates a cache that that requires climbing down and up a steep ravine and gives it a terrain rating of 3.5. No need to store the cache information (or checksum of such, or any extra data, even) per log when on that side of the line it's all just duplicate info until the next edit; it already has the lookup info needed: log date. Why smother it? You're never going to be able to prevent all disappointments, and I see no pressing need to prevent disappointment to begin with. Rating: 89%. Add to Cart. The OP would help with this, but I imagine the application for the request is extremely limited and probably not worth the effort. For example: Geocaching Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. One is the easiest. FWIW, this doesn't have to be implemented in the massive storage cost method most people seem to think it would be (via storing the D/T with logs). The log's only interest is the lookup date, so snapshot the cache data before the edits are saved and store with the edit date. I cannot see the difference between the current query that constructs the Date Found calendar and one which would make the D/T matrix (if the D/T was included in the GL log type, like the found date is now). Found Geocaches. B. Or, alternatively, to help avoid numerous quick-saves when a CO may edit until they're satisfied, only store the cache data as of the beginning of the current date. Items 61-99 of 99. One is the easiest. And it also would help a great deal to allow to add additional hints to a difficult puzzle cache after a while and decreasing the D-rating accordingly wthout annoying those who. The coordinates of the cache are changed to the coordinates of the newest addition, as well as the DT rating. If the log is to show the D/T at the time of finding then would the stats also need to be calculated based on the log rather than the cache? I just don't agree with the new D/T rating, and sure don't feel like we "earned" it. If we were to restrict features because they allegedly make it easier to cheat (as if you couldn't already), then there should not be a feature to alter a cache's coordinates. They are only cheating themselves. ... dunno. It's an alternative solution that reaps other useful benefits besides helping 'incidental side games' (of which, I'm obviously not a serious contender). We here in teh forumz like to make suggestions and discuss them when there are ideas put forward, towards solving what even very few people might consider something worth improving. Geocaching Holiday Geocoin . Found Geocaches. This request is precipitated by discussions around losing one's completed grid when a cache's D/T rating is changed: http://forums.Groundspeak.com/GC/index.php?showtopic=323560. The easiest way to look at the caches near you is to look at the map either on your phone or on your computer. Copyright © 2000-2020 Groundspeak, Inc. DBA Geocaching. To me that seems more straightforward (one or two options, plus other stuff I'm already doing if something like that happens right now). If the only people it's relevant to are the people who care about it, then providing the option to the logger seems the best case. Value 1. I think a better solution is just to shrug. 31 Items . From what I've seen this issue arises most when a CO changes a property and someone no longer qualifies or don't like that there's a hole in their stats. Geocaching Gift Ideas; Gift Certificates; Clearance. Add to Compare. A CO creates a cache that that requires climbing down and up a steep ravine and gives it a terrain rating of 3.5. Skip to … (again, waxing over this because it's what I do for a living; not really intent on any of this actually being implemented in whatever way, though it would be nice to have, even if YMMV, and for me at least, it's fun to work through). Conclusion: Both apps restrict basic members, so premium membership is a huge advantage to get the most out of both 14. Condor Side Kick Geocaching Pouch- Green . In addition, most of those modeled after the original Well Rounded Cacher Challenge, disallow including caches that have had their D/T ratings changed. Ideally, I'd have it set up that the finds do refer to the stats as of the date of the find; in some manner. Sure, sometimes ratings are changed to reflect a real change, but often they are changed because they have just always been inaccurate. If you contribute to this wiki, you agree to provide permission to others under this license. The CO corrects the D/T ratings and indicates that they should replace the original values. St. Louis Area Geocachers Association (SLAGA), https://geocaching.fandom.com/wiki/Terrain_Rating?oldid=5308. Partial mitigation: Day-edited single snapshot; Log option to lookup cache stat by log date or use current listing stats; Perhaps allow the CO to mark legitimate edit snapshots? Just playing off a concept of a simple changelog. Visit Geocaching.com to see just how many geocaches are nearby and to learn how to start finding them. Least impact - let the logger decide whether the properties for their own stats are as of the date they logged it or not. In any case it would/could have an effect on the grids that are shown on diverse stats and badge system sites. Add more UI features for snapshots and dates, and returning to past logs to change which values to use if a cache changes? If the Difficulty is only changed once 3 years after publish and it gets another 2 years of life before archival, it's easy for the system to determine that Find logs posted pre-change used the first D, and those after used the updated D. No need to snapshot duplicate data for every log. 4 Reviews. A 3-star terrain in British Columbia, Canada is most likely going to be a very different experience from a 3-star terrain in Amsterdam, Holland. Upload or insert images from URL. If that 'system' is immitated and automated with cache edits on the server end, I see it being more beneficial than not; but that's IMO. Select Setup > Geocaches. Use case 1. Later a CO decides their series is no longer 5T because the water level has lowered, and the stats are now skewed to easy walks. Special Price $9.10 Regular Price $12.99. Items On sale; Last Chance Items; Account . The proposed solution is to implement an additional feature few people will understand, and then "partially mitigate" the additional problems that feature causes by making the feature more and more complicated. Send us an email. It’s one of the best GPS devices for geocaching if you’re on slightly more of a budget but still after a quality Garmin product. If this forum is really a black hole, then there's not much point in arguing. When you submit a geocache for publication, you must specify ratings for difficulty and terrain using a 5-star scale. Parents may want to remain heavily involved in the chase, instead of letting kids roam on their own; with a little help, the activity can be a good chance to reinforce valuable geography, map reading, and other skills and get your kids excited about exploring the world around them. Yes, because with the new system you could create a sock account, publish a couple of caches, change the D/T ratings while repeatedly finding them, and so fill up your D/T grid with historical finds of a single cache. There are millions of geocaches worldwide, just waiting for you to find them. The point of the difficulty/terrain ratings is to communicate the general nature of the geocaching experience to potential seekers, so they can better assess whether they should attempt to find the cache. As far as country and flag, I mention it to see if there is support for freezing similarly to date of a find, and clearing up amiguities such as St.Martin / Sint Maarten, and the other 'nations' that comprised Netherlands Antilles. Remember when South Sudan split off from Sudan? At least there are options. FWIW, I've seen logs that included a sting of characters at the end, where this string of characters encoded information on the state of the cache at the time the finder found it: size, difficulty and terrain ratings, finder's impression of what the difficulty and terrain ratings should have been, subtype (e.g., challenge vs puzzle vs night cache). Terms of Use | Privacy Policy A CO creates a cache and inadvertently switches the intended values but doesn't noticed until a month after it's been published. Honestly, Groundspeak seem so good at breaking things with their releases I shudder to think of the consequences of changing the table containing cache logs. Items On sale; Last Chance Items; Account . Having the snapshot means stats can still show the user found them when they were actually 5T's. I don't understand the concept of "cheating" in this non-competitive hobby.   Pasted as rich text. But even ignoring all the logging and stat stuff - as a database dev, it does still irk me that there's no changelog for caches (to whatever detail), and that user find statistics aren't actually describing the statistics of the user's finds, only the current properties of caches that the user has marked as found. Trackables. $9.99. Select the option based on the most difficult parts of the cache. First time completing a r/Geocaching Challenge? There are, of course, pros and cons to any solution for this. Allows you to edit the number of geocaches found. What's it about? This will be the go to place for charts, top lists, statbars, compares, achievements and map tools. The cost would be in implementation, as well as providing meaningful API methods to access the information, not so much in storage. Geocaching Gift Ideas; Gift Certificates; Clearance. I'd hardly consider it a massive storage cost. Dipping The act of logging a trackable into a geocache, and immediately logging it back into one's possession. Best GPS for Geocaching to Buy in 2019 (Top 8 Reviews) The best GPS for geocaching is a device that allows determining the location of a person or an object in different parts of the world. Our support team will reply as soon as possible. As a CO, knowing people may be needing certain stats, if I change something the cache listing I make sure to include a note with the date of the change and what was changed - this was more relevant before automated statistic checking was required, for any challenge owner to decide whether a qualifying user can use my edited cache or not (or verify prior qualifications that no longer qualify) - but I generated my own 'change log' for the record, being considerate of challenge cachers. Therefore, every now and then when a cap is added on top of a mountain, my average terrain rating takes a big leap for a week. Assuming you took one byte each for D and T (though theoretically one byte is enough to store both, if you want to be stingy), with the number of logs currently in the database it adds up to just on 1Gb of extra data -- a rounding error when you consider the storage required for the log text itself. Having them as a more accurate historical account would help the user statistics actually be more like what they're intended to display. A terrain rating of 3.5 might be correct before a bridge across a ravine was built, but might not be accurate under the current state of the cache. Geocaching hunts range from simple but exciting challenges to complex problem-solving adventures. By Allows you to display the geocache list by names or codes. Add to Compare. $1.99. Check out [these important guidelines in the subreddit wiki... jump to content. So a heavy user would hit that extra hop 62,000 times a day and that wouldn't load the system. 4 Reviews. Then each log just needs to save the checksum of the then-current cache data. How to combine those two? I do find value in this feature, because currently stats only display current cache properties, not necessarily the statistics of your caching career based on your actual previous accomplishments.